Legally reviewed by Alexander Begum, Personal Injury Attorney
Key Takeaways
- You can sue your insurance company in Texas. A policyholder can sue its own insurer for an unpaid covered claim, and the Texas Insurance Code adds claims for unfair settlement practices and late payment.
- You usually cannot sue the other driver’s insurer directly. The Supreme Court of Texas calls this the “no direct action” rule: you pursue the at-fault driver first, and the insurer pays after liability is settled by agreement or judgment.
- Your insurer has to meet deadlines. It must acknowledge a claim within 15 days and accept or reject it within 15 business days after receiving what it asked for, with written reasons for a denial.
- Late payment carries a penalty. An insurer that owes a first-party claim and pays late owes 18% a year interest plus reasonable attorney’s fees.
- Underinsured motorist claims work differently. Your insurer generally need not pay UIM benefits until the other driver’s liability and your damages are determined.
- Two deadlines matter most. An Insurance Code claim must be filed within two years of the unfair act, after at least 60 days’ written notice to the insurer.
Yes, you can sue your insurance company in Texas if it refuses to pay a covered claim, drags its feet or handles your claim unfairly. What you generally cannot do is sue the at-fault driver’s insurance company directly; Texas law makes you go through the driver first, and that insurer’s duties run to its own customer, not to you.
After a Texas car accident, you may be dealing with several insurers at once: the other driver’s liability carrier, your own PIP and collision coverage, and your uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Your right to sue depends on which one is refusing to pay. If an insurer has already denied you, our Texas bad faith insurance lawyers can review the denial for free.
Can I Sue a Car Insurance Company?
It depends on whose insurance company it is. A first-party claim is on your own policy (PIP, collision, uninsured/underinsured motorist or homeowners coverage). A third-party claim is against the liability policy of the person who hurt you, whose contract is with that person, not you.
| Question | Your own insurer (first-party) | Other driver’s insurer (third-party) |
|---|---|---|
| Can you sue it directly? | Yes, for breach of the policy and for Insurance Code violations. | Generally no, until the driver’s liability is fixed by agreement or judgment. |
| Who owes you the duty? | The insurer owes you a duty to deal fairly and in good faith. | The insurer’s duties run to its own policyholder, the driver. |
| Prompt Payment Act (Ch. 542) | Applies, with an 18% a year interest penalty for late payment. | Does not apply; it covers first-party claims only. |
| Unfair settlement practices (§541.060) | You can sue for them. | The statute gives a third-party claimant no cause of action. |
| Who you sue instead | The insurer itself. | The at-fault driver (and anyone else responsible). |
Sources: Texas Insurance Code §541.060 and §542.051; Supreme Court of Texas opinions listed below.
When Can You Sue Your Own Insurance Company?
Texas gives policyholders several grounds, and most require showing the policy covers the loss.
The insurer breached the policy
An insurance policy is a contract. If your claim is covered and the insurer refuses to pay it, or pays less than the policy requires, you can sue for breach of contract. The policy language controls, so start with a full copy of your policy.
Unfair settlement practices
Chapter 541 of the Texas Insurance Code lists claim-handling practices that are illegal when used against a policyholder. Under §541.060, they include:
- Misrepresenting a material fact or policy provision about the coverage at issue.
- Failing to attempt in good faith a prompt, fair and equitable settlement once the insurer’s liability has become reasonably clear.
- Failing to promptly give a reasonable explanation, based on the policy and the facts, for denying a claim or offering a compromise.
- Failing within a reasonable time to affirm or deny coverage.
- Refusing to pay a claim without conducting a reasonable investigation.
Section 541.151 lets a person who suffers actual damages from one of these practices sue for them. For warning signs to watch for, see 5 signs your insurance company may be acting in bad faith.
The insurer paid too late
The Texas Prompt Payment of Claims Act (Insurance Code Chapter 542, Subchapter B) puts deadlines on first-party claims. These are the main ones:
| Step | Insurer’s deadline | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Acknowledge the claim, start investigating and request what it needs | 15 days after notice of the claim | §542.055 |
| Accept or reject the claim in writing | 15 business days after receiving everything it requested | §542.056(a) |
| Explain a rejection | The rejection notice must state the reasons | §542.056(c) |
| Extension if it needs more time | Must say why within the same period, then decide within 45 more days | §542.056(d) |
| Pay an accepted claim | 5 business days after notifying you it will pay | §542.057 |
| Penalty for delay | 18% a year interest plus attorney’s fees once payment is late (generally more than 60 days without another statutory period) | §§542.058, 542.060 |
Source: Texas Insurance Code Chapter 542, Subchapter B. Surplus lines insurers and suspected arson claims have longer periods.
The penalty applies only if the insurer actually owes the claim. Under §542.060, it then pays the claim plus 18% a year interest and reasonable attorney’s fees; weather-related property claims under Chapter 542A get a lower rate. Auto PIP has its own clock: §1952.156 requires payment within 30 days after the insurer receives satisfactory proof of the claim.
The insurer acted in bad faith
Texas courts also recognize a common-law duty of good faith and fair dealing. In USAA Texas Lloyds Co. v. Menchaca (2018), the Supreme Court of Texas explained that because insurers control the evaluation and denial of claims, they must “deal fairly and in good faith with their insureds.” The court also held that, as a general rule, you cannot recover policy benefits as damages for a statutory violation unless the policy entitled you to them, though you can recover for an injury truly independent of the lost benefits.
Can You Sue the Other Driver’s Insurance Company?
Not directly, at least not at first. Under Texas’s general rule, an injured person cannot sue the at-fault person’s insurer “until the tortfeasor’s liability has been finally determined by agreement or judgment,” the Supreme Court of Texas wrote in In re Essex Insurance Co. (2014). The rule applies even to a suit asking only for a declaration about coverage.
The Insurance Code agrees. Section 541.060(b) says the list of unfair settlement practices “does not provide a cause of action to a third party” making a claim against the insurer’s policyholder. So if the other driver’s adjuster lowballs you or blames you for the crash, you have no bad faith claim against that insurer.
Here is what you do instead:
- Make a liability claim with the at-fault driver’s insurer, backed by medical records, bills, proof of lost income and your Texas crash report.
- If it does not settle, sue the at-fault driver (and anyone else responsible). The driver’s insurer normally defends the case and pays up to its policy limits.
- File within the two-year deadline in CPRC §16.003; see our Texas personal injury statute of limitations guide.
Fault still matters. Under §33.001, you recover nothing if you are more than 50% responsible, which is why adjusters often argue you were partly at fault.
Denied, delayed or lowballed? Talk to a lawyer before you sign anything. A release you sign for a partial payment can end the claim, and the two-year clock on an Insurance Code claim starts when the unfair act happens, not when you finish treatment. Call (956) 982-1800 for a free consultation about which insurer you can hold responsible.
Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Claims
UM/UIM coverage is where a car accident claim often becomes a dispute with your own insurer. Every Texas auto policy includes it unless a named insured rejects it in writing (§1952.101). If the at-fault driver has no insurance, or only the Texas minimum of $30,000 per person and $60,000 per crash for injuries (Transp. Code §601.072), it can pay the rest up to your limits.
The catch is timing. UIM pays what you are “legally entitled to recover” from the other driver, minus what that driver’s insurer paid or owes (§1952.106). In In re State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. (2021), the Supreme Court of Texas repeated its rule that a UIM insurer’s “contractual obligation to pay benefits does not arise until liability and damages are determined.” In practice, that means:
- Your insurer can refuse to pay UIM benefits until the other driver’s fault and your damages are proven, often in what the court called a “car crash” trial against your own insurer.
- Bad faith claims against your UIM carrier usually wait until that question is decided.
- Many policies require your insurer’s consent before you settle with the at-fault driver, so check yours first.
See also do I need uninsured motorist insurance? and what happens if you wreck with someone who doesn’t have insurance.
What Can You Recover If You Win?
- Breach of the policy: The benefits the policy owed you.
- Chapter 541 violations: Actual damages, court costs and reasonable attorney’s fees, and up to three times actual damages if the insurer acted knowingly (§541.152).
- Prompt-payment violations: The claim plus 18% a year interest and reasonable attorney’s fees (§542.060).
No statute sets a typical value; the policy and the insurer’s conduct decide it.
Steps to Take Before You Sue
- Get the denial in writing. On a first-party claim, the insurer must state its reasons for a rejection (§542.056(c)).
- Get your whole policy. Request a complete copy, including the declarations page and endorsements.
- Keep a claim diary. Log every call, the adjuster’s name and what was said, and save every letter and estimate.
- Do not sign a release for a partial payment. Section 541.060(a)(6) limits an insurer’s power to enforce a full release after a partial payment.
- Consider a TDI complaint. The Texas Department of Insurance takes complaints through its insurance complaint page. A complaint does not stop any deadline.
- Send the 60-day notice. Before filing a Chapter 541 lawsuit, give the insurer written notice of the specific complaint and your damages and attorney’s fees at least 60 days ahead (§541.154), unless you must file at once to beat the deadline.
- Watch the deadlines. A Chapter 541 claim must be filed within two years of the unfair act or its discovery (§541.162), and Texas voids any policy deadline to sue that is shorter than two years (CPRC §16.070).
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue a car insurance company?
Yes, if it is your own insurer and it refused to pay a covered claim, paid late or handled the claim unfairly. You can sue for breach of the policy and under Texas Insurance Code Chapters 541 and 542. You generally cannot sue the at-fault driver’s insurer directly; you sue the driver.
Can I sue my insurance company for taking too long?
Yes, on a first-party claim the insurer actually owes. Chapter 542 sets deadlines to acknowledge, decide and pay. An insurer that owes the claim and misses them pays 18% a year interest plus reasonable attorney’s fees (a lower rate applies to weather-related property claims).
Can you sue the other driver’s insurance company in Texas?
Generally no. Under Texas’s “no direct action” rule, you cannot sue the at-fault driver’s insurer until the driver’s liability is fixed by a settlement or a judgment, and §541.060(b) gives third-party claimants no unfair-settlement claim. Your claim is against the driver.
How much is a bad faith lawsuit worth?
There is no standard value. A policyholder who wins can recover the benefits owed, actual damages, court costs and attorney’s fees, and up to three times actual damages if the insurer acted knowingly (§541.152). The facts of the claim decide the amount.
Will insurance pay out if it was my fault?
Your own coverages often do. Texas PIP pays medical bills and lost income regardless of fault unless you rejected it in writing, and collision coverage pays for your car if you bought it. If you were only partly at fault, you can still recover from the other driver as long as you were not more than 50% responsible.
How long do I have to sue my insurance company in Texas?
A Chapter 541 claim must be filed within two years of the unfair act or its discovery (§541.162). A policy may set its own deadline for contract claims, but Texas voids any deadline shorter than two years (CPRC §16.070). Send the 60-day notice early.
Do I need a lawyer to sue my insurance company?
The law does not require one, but insurers defend these cases with experienced lawyers, and the notice, coverage and UIM timing rules are easy to get wrong. A winning policyholder can recover reasonable attorney’s fees under Chapters 541 and 542. The Law Giant offers a free consultation. No fee unless we win.
Insurer Won’t Pay? Get The Giant on Your Side
Every week you wait on an insurer that will not pay is a week closer to the two-year deadline. The Law Giant’s wrongful denial lawyers represent policyholders across Texas, including in San Antonio, Houston, Dallas, McAllen and the Rio Grande Valley.
The consultation is free. No fee unless we win. Call (956) 982-1800 or contact us online.
Sources and authorities
- Texas Insurance Code: §541.060, §541.151, §541.152, §541.154, §541.162.
- Texas Insurance Code: §§542.051-542.060; Chapter 542A.
- Texas Insurance Code: §1952.101, §1952.106, §1952.152, §1952.156.
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code: §16.003, §16.070, §33.001.
- Texas Transportation Code: §601.072.
- Supreme Court of Texas, USAA Texas Lloyds Co. v. Menchaca, No. 14-0721 (2018).
- Supreme Court of Texas, In re State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., No. 19-0791 (2021).
- Supreme Court of Texas, In re Essex Insurance Co., No. 13-1006 (2014).
- Texas Department of Insurance, Get help with an insurance complaint.
This article is general information about Texas law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its facts; talk to a lawyer about yours. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.